Naturalism vs. Theism:
The Carrier-Wanchick Debate (2006)


Does God exist? Or is nature all there is? Richard Carrier and Tom Wanchick debate this question below.

Who We Are

What We Are Debating

The Rules We Followed

Wanchick's Opening Statement
Carrier's Opening Statement

Carrier's First Rebuttal
Wanchick's First Rebuttal

Wanchick's Second Rebuttal
Carrier's Second Rebuttal

Carrier's Closing Statement
Wanchick's Closing Statement

Final Assessment